The red sash. The bandana. The parrot on the shoulder, the buckled shoes, the peg leg, the treasure chart with a spot marked on it. None of it comes from the historical record of actual pirates, and almost all of it comes from one man: Howard Pyle, an illustrator working out of Wilmington, Delaware, between the 1880s and his death in 1911.
An Illustrator, Not a Historian
Pyle was born in Wilmington in 1853 and made his name first with a retelling of an older legend, The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood, published in 1883 after he had been contributing to Harper’s Weekly since 1878. His pirate work grew out of the same magazine career: illustrated stories and articles for Harper’s publications through the 1880s and 1890s, brought together after his death into the 1921 collection Howard Pyle’s Book of Pirates. He was never trying to document history. He was illustrating adventure fiction, and where the historical record was silent, he simply invented.
Inventing a Costume From Nothing
That invention was necessary because almost no reliable visual record of what actual Golden Age pirates wore had survived into Pyle’s time. He filled the gap by borrowing from other sources entirely, particularly the exoticized way 19th-century artists depicted Romani dress: loose shirts, sashes wound at the waist, bandanas, and gold hoop earrings. He paired that invented wardrobe with tricorn hats and buckled shoes drawn from general 18th-century fashion, and dropped his pirates into dramatic, theatrical poses — marooned on a beach, dividing plunder on a ship’s deck, walking a captive across a plank. The costume had no basis in any pirate’s actual sea chest. It simply looked right, and it stuck.
The Paintings That Outlasted the Stories
Pyle’s single most famous pirate image is Marooned, a 1909 oil painting of a solitary pirate sitting on an empty beach in his invented red sash and headscarf, now held by the Delaware Art Museum. It, along with his illustrations for stories like “Walking the Plank,” fixed the template that later pirate art would copy almost without variation, regardless of whether the specific story being illustrated had anything to do with Pyle’s original tales.
The Student Who Carried It to Treasure Island
Pyle taught illustration at Drexel Institute from 1894 to 1900 and then ran his own school in Wilmington, training a generation of American illustrators known collectively as the Brandywine School. His most influential student was N.C. Wyeth, who studied under Pyle and went on to illustrate a 1911 edition of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island using visual conventions drawn directly from his teacher’s work. Wyeth’s illustrations, in turn, became the version of Long John Silver and his crew that most 20th-century readers actually pictured.
From Canvas to Hollywood to Disneyland
The line runs forward from there with remarkably little interruption. Costume designers for Errol Flynn’s pirate films of the 1930s and 1940s drew on the Pyle-Wyeth look; decades later, Disney Imagineers working on the Pirates of the Caribbean attraction translated the same two-dimensional conventions into three-dimensional animatronics and sets. The specific outfit millions of people now picture when they hear the word “pirate” is not a costume any historical pirate ever wore. It is closer to a piece of art history than a piece of maritime history — one illustrator’s 19th-century guess, repeated so often it became fact in everything but the record.
Sources consulted: Wikipedia, “Howard Pyle”; L. Kilroy-Ewbank, “How Howard Pyle Shaped the Iconic Look of Pirates.”
Leave a Reply