Most pirate movies borrow their villains from the Golden Age of Piracy and leave it at that. Aardman’s 2012 stop-motion comedy did something stranger: it kidnapped Charles Darwin, put him on a pirate ship, and built its entire plot around a thought-to-be-extinct dodo. The film was released in the UK as The Pirates! In an Adventure with Scientists! and everywhere else, including the United States, as The Pirates! Band of Misfits — one of the few times a studio has changed a title specifically because American audiences, test screenings suggested, didn’t know what “scientists” had to do with pirates.
A Dodo Named Polly
The plot follows an enthusiastic but hopeless pirate captain, voiced by Hugh Grant, whose crew boards what they believe is an ordinary merchant vessel and comes away instead with the HMS Beagle and its naturalist passenger, Charles Darwin (David Tennant). Darwin examines the captain’s beloved “parrot,” Polly, and delivers the film’s premise: she is not a parrot at all but a dodo, believed extinct, and quite possibly the last of her kind — a status scientists call being an “endling.” Mistaking the scientific fame on offer for a cash prize, the captain sets off a chain of schemes involving the Royal Society, a villainous Queen Victoria (Imelda Staunton), and a rival buccaneer, Cutlass Liz, voiced by Salma Hayek. Martin Freeman, Jeremy Piven, and Brian Blessed round out a voice cast built almost entirely from British comic actors rather than American stars.
Three Centuries, Mashed Together on Purpose
The joke only works because the film is cheerfully indifferent to when any of this actually happened. The Golden Age pirate archetypes it plays with — eyepatches, peg legs, a captain obsessed with winning “Pirate of the Year” — belong to the late 1600s and early 1700s. The real HMS Beagle’s voyage carrying Darwin ran from December 1831 to October 1836. Queen Victoria did not take the throne until 1837, after that voyage had already ended, and the Darwin of the film, already a minor celebrity scientist, bears little resemblance to the twenty-two-year-old unknown naturalist who actually sailed on the Beagle. None of this is an error so much as the entire design: the film treats “pirate,” “Victorian,” and “natural history” as one shared costume box rather than three different centuries, and it is explicit enough about the gag that it builds an actual joke around Darwin’s real theory of natural selection late in the story.
Built by Hand, One Frame at a Time
Behind the jokes, The Pirates! is a genuine stop-motion production from Aardman Animations, the studio behind Wallace & Gromit, made in partnership with Sony Pictures Animation and directed by Peter Lord with co-director Jeff Newitt. Physical puppets and sets were combined with computer-generated elements for the sea and some backgrounds — a hybrid approach Aardman had been refining for years by the time this film, based on Gideon Defoe’s 2004 novel of the same UK title, went into production.
A Modest Hit That Found Its Audience Later
The film earned about $123 million worldwide against a $55 million budget, and critics were considerably warmer to it than the opening-weekend American audience was: it holds an 87 percent approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes against a far cooler “B” grade from the CinemaScore exit-poll audience — the lowest of any Aardman release — and it picked up an Academy Award nomination for Best Animated Feature. As of a few years after release, it ranked as the fourth-highest-grossing stop-motion animated film ever made, a quiet testament to a joke built on a pirate captain who cannot tell a parrot from the last dodo on Earth.
Sources consulted: Wikipedia’s entry on “Pirates!” (2012 film); contemporaneous coverage of the HMS Beagle voyage and Queen Victoria’s accession.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.