The Richest Pirate Haul in History: Levasseur and Taylor’s Capture of the Nossa Senhora do Cabo

The grave of pirate captain Olivier Levasseur, known as La Buse, at the Cimetière marin de Saint-Paul on Réunion island

Ask most people to name the richest prize a pirate ever took, and they’ll say Henry Every’s capture of the Ganj-i-Sawai in 1695. Among historians who have actually added up the numbers, though, a different, far less famous heist usually tops the list: the capture of a crippled Portuguese galleon off a repair anchorage in the Indian Ocean in April 1721, by two pirate captains who barely had to fire a shot.

A Crippled Galleon Off Réunion

The Nossa Senhora do Cabo was a roughly 700-ton Portuguese East India ship sailing home from Goa to Lisbon, carrying the outgoing Viceroy of Portuguese India and the Bishop of Goa — the Patriarch of the East Indies — along with their households, baggage, and, as it turned out, an extraordinary amount of portable wealth. A storm en route snapped the ship’s main mast, and to keep the crippled vessel from capsizing its crew threw all seventy-two of its cannons overboard. Unarmed and unable to sail properly, the Cabo anchored off Réunion (then called Bourbon Island) to make repairs. It was there that the pirate captains John Taylor and Olivier Levasseur, cruising together, found it. With no guns to answer with, the galleon’s crew could offer essentially no resistance, and the pirates took the richest ship either of them would ever see without having to fight for it.

What the Hold Actually Held

The haul was less the usual pirate mix of trade goods and coin than a floating treasury. Alongside bars of gold and silver and chests of gold coin, the pirates found diamonds, pearls, silk, paintings, and a cargo of ecclesiastical treasure the Bishop had been carrying from the cathedral at Goa — among it a solid gold cross set with diamonds, rubies, and emeralds so heavy it reportedly took three men to carry it aboard Levasseur’s ship. By most accounts the pirates left the ship’s passengers personally unmolested; with a hold already this rich, robbing the Viceroy’s pockets hardly seemed worth the trouble.

Splitting a Fortune

The pirate companies sailed to Madagascar to divide the spoils, losing a crew member named Jasper Seagar to illness along the way. There, by the accounts that survive, each ordinary pirate received roughly £50,000 worth of gold coin and forty-two diamonds apiece — a staggering individual share for the period — while Taylor and Levasseur split the remaining bulk goods between them. Levasseur kept the golden cross for himself. Modern historians estimate the total prize at up to roughly £1 million sterling in the money of the day, which would make it probably the single richest haul of the entire golden age of piracy; some popular accounts push the modern-dollar equivalent far higher still, though those conversions rest on much shakier ground than the basic fact that this was an enormous prize.

Bigger Than Every’s Gunsway?

Every’s 1695 seizure of the Ganj-i-Sawai is the more famous “biggest pirate haul in history,” partly because it triggered an international diplomatic crisis and a manhunt that made Every a legend in his own lifetime. But by the reckonings historians have made of each prize’s actual value, the Cabo‘s cargo likely outweighed it. The Cabo simply never got the same press: no outraged Mughal emperor, no English East India Company scrambling to save its trading privileges, just a quiet division of loot on a Madagascar beach that left far less of a paper trail for later writers to seize on.

What Became of the Two Captains

Their partnership didn’t last. The pirate companies split up in 1722, and Taylor eventually sailed for the Caribbean, where the Spanish governor of Portobello pardoned him and his men in exchange for handing over his ship, the Cassandra. Taylor later returned to his family in Jamaica and is reported to have settled in Cuba, running a plantation and a small trading vessel as late as 1744. Levasseur’s end was far grimmer: he turned down a 1724 amnesty rather than hand back the treasure the French government wanted returned, hid out in the Seychelles, and was eventually captured near Fort Dauphin, Madagascar. He was taken to Saint-Denis, Réunion — the very island where the Cabo had been taken — and hanged there on 7 July 1730.

The Cryptogram That (Probably) Never Existed

Levasseur’s name is permanently attached to one of pirate lore’s most durable legends: that at the gallows he flung a necklace bearing a seventeen-line coded cryptogram into the crowd, shouting for whoever could decipher it to find his treasure. Treasure hunters on Réunion and the Seychelles still chase that cipher today. The trouble is that no document from Levasseur’s own lifetime mentions a necklace, a cryptogram, or any gallows speech at all; the cipher first surfaces in a 1934 book by the French historian Charles de La Roncière, two centuries after the hanging. Most historians now treat it as a twentieth-century invention grafted onto a genuinely rich pirate’s story — which, given what Levasseur and Taylor actually got away with off Réunion nine years earlier, hardly needed the embellishment.

Sources consulted: Wikipedia’s “Olivier Levasseur” and “John Taylor (pirate)” entries; GoldenAgeOfPiracy.org, “Capture of the Nossa Senhora do Cabo”; National Geographic, “These pirates left the Caribbean behind—and stole the biggest booty ever.”

Leave a Reply