On April 26, 1717, the pirate ship Whydah Gally went down in a nor’easter off Cape Cod, taking Captain Samuel Bellamy and most of his roughly 146-man crew with her. When divers finally located the wreck in 1984 under more than 30 feet of sand, the site did not hand them tricorne hats or eye patches. It handed them a Scottish-made flintlock pistol inlaid with brass dragons, still loaded with shot and wadding, and nearly 400 pieces of West African goldwork carried aboard as plunder. It is a better guide to how a real pirate crew looked than any costume shop.
Workwear, Not a Uniform
Most pirates dressed the way any working sailor of the 17th and 18th centuries dressed, because most pirates were working sailors first. Clothes were cut from hard-wearing linen and wool — broadcloth, kersey, shag, and Welsh plains — in practical blues, tans, dark greens, whites, and greys. Ordinary crew wore short jackets called “fearnoughts,” made of heavy blue or grey cloth built for a rolling deck, while officers wore theirs a little longer, ending around mid-thigh. Trousers were baggy and often cut bell-bottomed so they could be rolled up quickly for scrubbing a deck or climbing rigging. None of it was designed to be recognized at a glance. It was designed to survive salt water and hard labor, because that is what most of a pirate’s day actually consisted of.
What a Captain Actually Wore
Where pirates did dress to be noticed was at the top of the crew, and largely because captains had first pick of whatever a captured ship carried. Bartholomew Roberts was captured, according to the 1724 account of his career, wearing a scarlet damask waistcoat and breeches, a red feather in his hat, and a gold chain with a diamond cross hung around his neck — a look striking enough that French sailors reportedly nicknamed him “le jolie rouge.” Bellamy himself was said to favor black velvet waistcoats, knee breeches, silk stockings, and shoes with silver buckles, worn along with four dueling pistols on ribbons rather than a single weapon at the hip. This was captured wealth worn as a statement, not a costume issued to the crew.
The Clichés That Don’t Hold Up
The eye patch, the gold hoop earring, and the knotted headscarf are the fastest way to draw “pirate” in two strokes, and the historical record for all three is thin. Earrings were considered effeminate for a sailor of the period rather than a badge of the trade, and eye patches turn up in almost no contemporary account despite plenty of injuries that might have justified one. The tricorne hat fares no better: its broad, upturned front brim was parade wear, not working gear, since it would have blocked a sailor’s view of the rigging overhead and blown off in the first stiff wind. On deck, a knit wool cap or a leather one was the more practical choice.
What the Wrecks Actually Preserve
Underwater archaeology tends to confirm the workwear picture rather than the storybook one, though not because pirates dressed more plainly than legend suggests — it’s that cloth rarely survives centuries in salt water while metal does. Buttons, buckles, and precious metal do most of the talking at a wreck site. That bias is visible at the Whydah itself: alongside the pistol, divers have recovered gold coins and rings, and roughly 200 brass manillas, the ring-shaped currency used for trade along the West African coast where Bellamy had taken the ship as a prize. What survives is less a record of pirate fashion than of pirate cargo — but it still tells the same story the clothing does. Pirates wore and carried whatever value came over the rail, fitted to a working sailor’s frame rather than built around a stage costume.
Sources consulted: World History Encyclopedia, “Pirate Clothing in the Golden Age of Piracy”; National Geographic, “We’re still finding treasure from this ‘golden age’ pirate shipwreck.”
Leave a Reply