St. Mary’s Island: The Pirate Depot Colonial Merchants Couldn’t Resist

1708 engraved map by Guillaume Delisle showing Madagascar and the surrounding Indian Ocean coast

By the early 1690s, a fortified trading post on a small island off the coast of Madagascar had become the most important supply base for pirates raiding the Indian Ocean. It was run not by a pirate captain but by a fugitive from Jamaica named Adam Baldridge, and it was kept stocked by merchants in New York who never left their counting houses.

A Harbor Built for Outlaws

Baldridge had fled Jamaica after killing a man, and by the early 1690s he had settled on Île Sainte-Marie, a narrow island off Madagascar’s east coast with a sheltered harbor that pirate crews returning from raids on Red Sea and Mughal shipping used as a stopover. He built a fortified post overlooking the anchorage and turned himself into the island’s indispensable middleman: pirates paid steep prices for rum, cloth, tools, and gunpowder, and Baldridge grew wealthy enough to live as a local strongman, keeping a household of enslaved people and dealing in captives alongside ordinary trade goods.

New York’s Secret Business Partner

None of this worked without a supply chain, and that chain ran straight to the docks of colonial New York. The merchant Frederick Philipse, a member of the provincial council, financed and dispatched trading voyages to Baldridge’s post, sending captains such as John Churcher and Thomas Mostyn with manufactured goods and liquor to trade for the plunder and captives pirates brought in. The arrangement linked the island directly to the era’s most notorious raiders: the pirate captain Thomas Tew called at St. Mary’s in 1693, and his ship Amity returned there in 1695, after Tew himself had been killed attacking the Mughal treasure ship Ganj-i-Sawai alongside Henry Every.

The Scheme Unravels

Baldridge’s position depended on the cooperation of the Malagasy communities around him, and in 1697 that cooperation collapsed after it became known that he had sold some local people into slavery. He fled the island amid the resulting anger, abandoning the post he had spent years building. Accounts of exactly what followed differ in their details, but the outcome was the same: St. Mary’s lost the man who had run it as a pirate entrepot for most of a decade.

The Crackdown

The New York end of the operation took a little longer to unwind. Royal officials had grown alarmed at how openly colonial merchants were bankrolling piracy against ships of nations England was not even at war with, and by 1699 the newly arrived governor, the Earl of Bellomont, had removed Philipse from his seat on the governing council and moved to shut the trade down. The timing was not an accident: Bellomont was the same governor who had backed William Kidd’s privateering voyage against pirates, only to watch Kidd turn pirate himself, and the Philipse scandal became part of the same broader reckoning with how deeply New York’s merchant class had profited from the Pirate Round.

Why It Mattered

St. Mary’s is a useful corrective to the image of piracy as purely an outlaw enterprise. The island depot could not have functioned without respectable colonial capital willing to launder plunder into ordinary trade goods, and for several years that capital flowed as openly as any legitimate shipping line. The pirates needed Baldridge; Baldridge needed Philipse; and Philipse, for a while, needed nobody to ask too many questions.

Sources consulted: Wikipedia (“Adam Baldridge,” “Pirate Round,” “Frederick Philipse”); Colin Woodard, The Republic of Pirates; goldenageofpiracy.org. The exact year Baldridge first established the post is given variously as the mid-1680s or the early 1690s in different accounts; this article uses the more conservative later estimate.

Leave a Reply